I started to put on Zoya Yummy the other day, and realized it appeared to look like Revlon Coastal Surf. Oh, wait... OPI No Room for the Blues too?
So I decided to grab all three, plus a fourth that looked similar, and compare them real quick.
Left -> Right (Index to Pinky): Zoya Yummy, Revlon Coastal Surf, OPI No Room for the Blues, and Orly Blue Collar.
 |
| Lightbox Shot |
 |
| Shade |
 |
| Full sun |
It is easier to see in person than in the pictures, but Zoya Yummy is slightly paler than the others, and Orly Blue Collar is a tad more aqua/green. I've shown them all at two coats, and each needed a third except Zoya Yummy. Revlon Coastal Surf and OPI No Room for the Blues were exact dupes in color, formula, application, and everything.
So let's break down the price comparison:
Zoya is $9 for 0.5 fl. oz. of product
Revlon is $7.99 for 0.4 fl. oz. of product (most expensive per fl. oz.)
OPI is $9 for 0.5 fl. oz. of product
and Orly is $8.50 for 0.6 fl. oz. of product (cheapest per fl. oz.)
I would say overall, if you own one of the first three, you don't need the others, but Orly is the odd man out.